Every year, Finance YouTube is flooded with "Top Stocks to Buy" videos. But once the views fade, nobody ever checks if they were actually right. Until now.
In this video, I created the ultimate Stock YouTuber Tier List by tracking the real returns of 16 popular influencers. I analyzed their "Top Picks for 2025" videos to see who is a market genius and who belongs in F-Tier.
I was ready to expose them for underperforming. I was wrong.
The Shocking Results: ✅ 14 out of 16 beat the S&P 500 (destroying the Index Fund narrative). 📉 The worst picker lost money during a historic Bull Market. 🚀 The winner achieved a massive +57.6% return (beating Wall Street's top Hedge Funds).
Who is the true "King of Stock Picking"? And which popular channels should you avoid? Let’s look at the data.
👇 Drop a Comment: Who is your favorite stock YouTuber? Did they make the list?
⏱️ Timestamps 00:00 - Why I Made this Youtuber Tier List 01:20 - 16 Investors + Adriconomics in F-Tier 02:37 - Tier F: Last Position 03:20 - Tier E... But Wait 04:15 - Tier D: The S&P 500 Benchmark 04:26 - Tier C: Beating the Index +20% 08:01 - Tier B: The +30% Club 09:26 - Tier A: The Guy Who Picked 20 Stocks 10:09 - Tier S: The Top 3 (Over 50% Returns!) 12:02 - Couch Investor Surprise 13:02 - My Top 5 Stock Picks for 2026
Disclaimer ⚠️ I am not a financial advisor. This video is for entertainment purposes only. The returns calculated are based on the specific "Top Stocks" videos published by these creators in late 2024/early 2025. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always do your own research.
